Genesee Street, Utica NY, John A. Roberts & Co.

Genesee Street, looking North, N.Y., c. 1911
(Oneida County Historical Society Archives)

John A. Roberts & Co., mirror


Object: Mirror
Description: Small hand Mirror with  John A. Roberts & Co., Utica, 1911 on back
Date: 1911
Height: 3.5”
Width: 2”

The last post left me with a big unanswered question:  What happened to the Butterfield House?  I noticed in the pictures that the building’s appearance changed over the years, but it appeared to keep the same footprint.

Butterfield House, Genesee St, John A. Roberts & Co.

Genesee Street, Looking North,
Utica, New York, c. 1930s
(Oneida County Historical Society Archives)

Was it significant exterior renovations?  By lucky happenstance, I came across a picture of the building by Grace Church with the label, “John A. Roberts & Co.”  That name quickly yielded the following search result:

“The Butterfield House, Utica, which
has been one of the prominent hostelries
of Central New York since the Civil War,
is to be closed May 1, 1910 and a five
story steel construction department store
to house the business of John A. Roberts
& Co., is to be erected on the site.” (“About the State: Brief News Paragraphs From All Parts of the Empire State,”  Homer Republican, Thursday, May 6, 1909, p 6.)

John A. Roberts & Co., Utica NY

Outside of New York City – The Greatest Department Store in the State
(Ad, The Syracuse Herald, Monday Evening, September 25, 1911, p 7.,

John A. Roberts & Co. did open at their new location in 1911, complete with a tea room and anything one might want to buy: collars, jabots and tabs, silk and spangled scarfs, ribbons, aprons, wall papers, gloves, men’s solid silk neckwear, women’s pure thread silk hosiery, umbrellas, drapery, cedar chests, odd decorative pieces for the home, kitchen cabinets, mission rockers, sewing machines, Armenian lace handkerchiefs, sterling silver bracelets, house coats, lace curtains, couch covers, velvet hats, dress trimmings, laces, etc.

John A. Roberts & Co., 1911, tea room

Tea Room 5th Floor,
Service for Gentlemen and Ladies-
is a delightful place to take Lunch or Dinner
Oneida County Historical Society Archives

The Oneida County Historical Society has several items related to John A. Roberts & Co. in our collection.  According to the accession paperwork for the mirror, “the John A. Roberts Co. of Utica was a delightful department store, and every year prior to Christmas they gave away a souvenir to their customers.  1911 was the year that the little pocket mirror was distributed.  We have a few of the other give away items and this is a nice addition to that collection.”


John A. Roberts & Co., Utica NY

Remember this for next Christmas: “Umbrellas as Christmas Gifts: A Most Appropriate, Useful and Acceptable Gift for Men, Women and Children.”
(Ad, The Syracuse Herald, Sunday Morning, December 17, 1911, p D-11.)

The Store of a Thousand Wonders

One thought on “The Store of a Thousand Wonders

  1. […] Fraser Department Store Firenotice the John A. Roberts & Co. Store, before it moved to its new […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s